It works by vote. We pick whoever would be most interesting with a little extra help, but we never got to pick the item delivered...

[that gets a laugh, though.] Don't think of it as unfair! Think of it as a good testimony to your character. From what I gathered, they gifted people they thought might make decent murderers, or people who could reasonably snap. [or it could just be because:] Immune players aren't on the list of candidates, either.