Oof, that's something I can well relate to. It'd be a lot easier to get creative, without those limitations. Mmm... The instruments in the music room were all classical, true. You're a more rock person, I take it? [as if the way she dresses and the 'guitar' thing on the info card didn't give away... BUT YES]

Fair enough. Now what to use? If there are other card games laying around that's not being played, you could recycle those. Otherwise, hm...

[Durable cardboard-like paper that's good for shuffling... Man. Book covers? Are they going to be missed?]